Saturday, 28 January 2017

Will China Replace America?


In 1823, US President James Monroe asserted that North and South America ‘are henceforth not to be considered as subjects for future colonization by any European powers’. But then he said that ‘we should consider any attempt on [the Europeans'] part to extend their system to any portion of this hemisphere as dangerous to our peace and safety’. Over the subsequent decades, the Monroe Doctrine gave the US the alibi to dominate the Americas for the sake of preserving the nation-state’s own territorial integrity. By 1898, as Prof John Mearsheimer notes, ‘the United States had become the first regional hegemon in modern history’. By hegemon, Mearsheimer means the only great power in a system of nation-states. A regional hegemon, in turn, is the only great power in a given region of the world. The Monroe Doctrine taught policymakers that domination of the Americas was the best way of maintaining security.

But the US did not stop there. After achieving regional hegemony, and realising that global hegemony was out of reach, American policymakers decided that they needed to prevent any other states from becoming regional hegemons. It was the ‘Manifest Destiny’ of the US to dominate its own region whilst preventing other states from doing the same with their regions. Here lies the reason for Woodrow Wilson’s declaration of war against Imperial Germany in April 1917: he wanted to prevent Germany from dominating Europe. This is also why Franklin Delano Roosevelt fought against Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany during the Second World War, despite the reluctance of his citizens and fellow politicians. George Kennan in 1947 recognised this fact in his recommendation that the US ‘contained’ the Soviet Union after the Second World War, since Eurasian monolith threatened to challenge American power. [1]

This is also why China will likely desire to replace the US as the dominant world power. Although still lagging behind the US GDP of $18.6T (as well as the EU’s GDP of $16.4T) China’s GDP rose to $11.2T in 2016.[2] Thus China is the second most wealthy state on Earth. And China’s economic power is being translated into military power. China, in other words, is trying to intimidate other states in Southeast Asia into submission to its hegemonic embrace of the region, just as the US intimidated Mexico and the colonial powers into bowing to American hegemony in the 19th century. China is becoming a regional hegemon.

But if China follows the American pattern of great power politics, it will not be a true regional hegemon until it rids Southeast Asia of American influence. This may or may not lead to Sino-American military confrontation, but it will very probably lead to a steady worsening of great power relations. Perhaps more significantly, China’s rise will shift not only the regional, but also the global balance of power in China’s favour. 

Currently, the global balance of power lies in America’s favour, as it spent $596B on defence in 2015—more than double China’s total of $215B.[3] But American power is being eroded. On 12 July 2016, for instance, an American-backed International Tribunal ruled against Chinese claims to rights in the South China Sea, in favour of the Philippines. Chinese state media had already said before the result that the tribunal risked ‘military confrontation’, since the arbitration would be ‘a farce’.[4] Thus China rejected the tribunal’s ruling and has continued to militarise islets in the South China Sea in order to become a regional hegemon and a global great power. On 23 January, for instance, China asserted its ‘indisputable sovereignty’ over parts of the South China Sea. Beijing also emphasised that Secretary Rex Tillerson’s remarks that ‘the island-building stops’ risked ‘devastating confrontation’.

But President Trump is doing the opposite of what is in America's interests. Instead of pressing forward with the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), and thus preventing China from dominating the region with its own trade deal, the President signed an executive order to withdraw the US from TPP, which would have involved 12 countries comprising 40% of global GDP. TPP would have allowed the US to dominate the South China Sea, thus preventing China from becoming a regional hegemon. But now that TPP no longer involves the US, China will be able to dominate the region through its 16-member trade deal comprising 30% of global GDP and 46% of the world’s population—the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP).

In short, China is rising. Its path toward regional hegemony is, it now seems, unstoppable. But once it dominates South-East Asia, its next objective will be clear: the containment of, or even encroachment on, American global power. Thus the tables have turned: once the US was the only regional hegemon. Now China is about to become a regional hegemon, perhaps capable of doing to America what America previously did to the Soviet Union. Today, China not only has its traditional New Year to celebrate, but it also has the opportunity to replace America as the mightiest great power that the world has ever seen. The spotlight of history is shifting—from Washington to Beijing, and from Donald Trump to Xi Jinping. 




[1] Mearsheimer, J. J. (2006). China’s Unpeaceful Rise. Current History, 105(690), 160-162. Retrieved from: http://bit.ly/2jHLiw8
[2] International Monetary Fund (2017). World Economic Outlook Database (April). Retrieved from: http://bit.ly/2qv2wnS
[3] Perlo-Freeman, S., Fleurant, A., Wezeman, P., & Wezeman, S. (2016). Trends in World Military Expenditure, 2015 (April). Stockholm International Peace Research Institute. Retrieved from: http://bit.ly/1RBl7UZ
[4] The Global Times (2016). Power game decides post-arbitration order (5 July). Retrieved from: http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/992320.shtml

Wednesday, 25 January 2017

Work of the Week: Democracy


The meaning of the word has never been fully clear, and its centrality to constitutions even less firm. I argue that democracy began its definitive process in antiquity, and continued it in Renaissance times, especially in Britain. But Britain, despite creating democracy’s definition, has often failed to fully grasp its essence. The path of true democracy never did run smooth…

Although a Greek word, democracy as we know it was not too favourable to the Ancient Greeks. Even the liberally minded Aristotle called democracy a ‘deviant’ constitutional arrangement, since it let the poor and uneducated rule over the rich and educated.[1] But his advocacy of a mixed constitution—a ‘polity’ of middle-class citizens ruling over the ‘polis’ or city-state—reflected the participatory nature of Athens at the time, where a large number of citizens could participate in the decision-making process. The Romans found this form of ‘direct democracy’ rather difficult to implement in a large empire, so used an early form of ‘representative democracy’ instead, where the ‘people and the senate of Rome’ (senatus populusque romanus: SPQR) was the empire’s banner.[2]

Two millennia later, one former part of the Roman Empire was re-discovering its political roots. But, despite its ‘renaissance’, England was simultaneously redefining democracy. Having created a Parliament which was beginning to hold the monarch to account on a number of issues, the little country was allowing obscure, poor people like Thomas Cromwell rise to become powerful figures in British politics. The ‘deviant’ constitution of democracy was beginning to take hold, and by the 20th century, ordinary people were allowed to vote regularly, secretly and freely on their chosen representative in government from a particular political party. Although the American founding father James Maddison beat the British to a ‘bill of rights’, constitutionally embodied rights for all British citizens were made explicit in the 1998 Human Rights Act, while the media and judiciary had already gained their independence. Hence, the British created a de facto definition for democracy as a system of (1) regular elections involving the secret ballot and different participating parties[3], (2) a broad spectrum of liberties, and (3) an independent media and judiciary. There is no objective definition of democracy, apart from the word’s etymology as a system where the ‘people’ (demos) have some impact on their ‘ruling’ (kratos). But there certainly is a subjective definition which can be agreed upon by, at the very least, the countries where ancient and modern democracy originated—namely, the European and North American states.

Nevertheless, the British have never owned the essence of democracy as a representative institution.[4] Hence, it is unsurprising that there are some essential flaws in the British ‘democratic’ system that, although meeting the definition of democracy, fail to fully grasp its essence. One such flaw, forming part of the UK’s democratic deficit, is the omnipresence of the monarch. The use of a possessive pronoun in Her/His Majesty’s Government is blatantly at odds with the concept of democracy as an institution of shared sovereignty. Whereas Thomas Hobbes[5] or Niccolò Machiavelli[6] would have approved of the ability of the Queen to oversee governmental policy and maintain her ability to intervene, the American ‘founding fathers’[7] most probably would not have approved. The Queen’s very job description as a monarch can be seen as a philosophical insult to democracy: the Queen may not be what democracy really ‘stands for’.[8] Nevertheless, the Queen lacks de facto political power, in that she does not have the ability to change legislation, influence who gets elected to the legislature, or select who forms the decision-making Government. Therefore, the Queen may be a symbol of monarchy, but would probably not be seriously understood to be a ruling monarch by Plato, Aristotle or Hobbes.

Furthermore, although meeting democracy’s definition, another institution undermining democracy’s essence in the UK is ‘first past the post’ (FPTP). Under this system, the House of Commons is made up of representatives from each British constituency, meaning that, if the largest party’s votes were equally distributed, it is possible that a party will win every single seat with, say, 52% of the vote. Although this never happens, since different parts of the UK vote differently, anomalies are frequent. For instance, the Liberal Democrats won only 1% of the seats with 8% of the May 2015 general election vote. By contrast, the Conservatives won 51% of the seats with only 37% of the overall vote. Therefore, a Conservative vote was more powerful than a Liberal Democratic vote, meaning that the Conservatives benefited disproportionately from FPTP whereas Liberal Democrats suffered disproportionately. In essence, this undermines to some extent the democratic principle of ‘one person one vote’ (OPOV), since someone’s voting power is largely dependent on where they live in the country. Of course, FPTP’s advantage is that it allows MPs to represent their region, not just their party, but Germany solves the problem by having a two-tier political system of regional representatives chosen by regional elections and national representatives chosen by a proportional part list system (an ‘additional member’ system).

On the other hand, the essence of democracy is thoroughly grasped by the embedding of democratic institutions. For instance, despite the fact that the Polity Project[9] ranked the UK as a democracy beforehand, the 1969 Representation of the People Act secured the democratic institutions of OPOV, secret ballot and regular elections. Moreover, continual consolidation of democratic institutions shows that the UK has grasped democracy’s essence and that democratic norms are still alive and well. In 2011, another Act of Parliament made sure that elections were held on a regular basis—every five years—demonstrating that UK governments continue to pursue a democratic UK in both mere definition and essence. This reflects the reality that democracy appears to form a continuum, where even ‘democracies’ can be more or less democratic.

Overall, democracy is a state-level institution defined by its comprising the following intra-state institutions: (1) competitive, regularly-held elections with a secret ballot with a choice of multiple parties; (2) independent media and judiciary; and (3) a variety of rights and liberties. The UK is definitively a democracy, since it contains these structures, but it lacks some total democracy in some areas. Although the institutions are generally present, sometimes democratic norms such as completely independent media fail to operate. Also, although one person has one vote, sometimes the FPTP system denies the practical effectiveness of this principle by favouring certain geographical regions. Moreover, the culture of secrecy lives on. Overall, therefore, the definition of democracy was met by the UK in the early twentieth century with universal suffrage, but the essence of democracy was yet to be fully consolidated. Indeed, it is democracy’s essence to be continually improving and continually consolidating, as mistakes appear to be part of human nature. Therefore, even if a ‘perfect democracy’ is never achieved in the UK, a ‘good’ one certainly can by maintaining the political desire to make HM Government more representative, more responsible, and more accountable to the people of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.





[1] Miller, F. (2008). Aristotle's political theory. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved from: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-politics/
[2] Crick, B. (2002). Democracy: a very short introduction (Vol. 75). Oxford Paperbacks.
[3] This constitutes ‘representative democracy’.
[4] Op cit.
[5] Hobbes, T. (2006 [1651]). Leviathan. A&C Black.
[6] Machiavelli, N. (2010 [1532]). The prince. University of Chicago Press.
[7] Hamilton, A., Madison, J., Jay, J., & Goldman, L. (2008). The federalist papers. Oxford University Press.
[8] Docherty, I. (2016). The Queen: cherished but not chosen? INK, Issue 11. Retrieved from: http://www.inkstudents.co.uk/article/the-queen-cherished-but-not-chosen
[9] Marshall, M. G., & Jaggers, K. (2015). Polity IV project: Political regime characteristics and transitions, 1800-2015. Center for Systematic Peace.

Sunday, 22 January 2017

Will History End?

The following is an extract from my article on the end of history, published on 8 January 2017:

“History” is an ambiguous word, albeit a common one. But defining history’s limits is worthwhile, as we all partake in history’s course every time we speak to a friend, write a letter or send a meme on Facebook. For philosophers Hegel, Kant and Marx, history was the history of ideas. In this way, if humanity agreed upon a common idea of how to organise society - be it freedom, democracy or communism - history could end. So will history end?

To read on, please visit: http://www.inkstudents.co.uk/article/will-history-end

The Shadow of Anarchy

The following is an extract from an article published on 5 November 2016, about the return of international anarchy following Putin's annexation of Crimea, inter alia:

The walls came down in 1989. Anarchy – the absence of global governance – came down with them, with the strengthening of the United Nations and the European Union. A period of peace in Europe followed. But new walls are forming. How worried should we be about the new superpower clashes in Europe, the Middle East and Asia, and how should our governments respond? Looming over the global cooperation of recent decades is anarchy’s long shadow.

            

In March 2014, Russia’s annexation of Crimea put the US into the spotlight. In a swift, bloodless move, Putin secured the warm water port at Sevastopol and strengthened his country’s security position. In the coming months, Russia was to give extensive support to separatist rebels in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Ukraine. But Putin did not stop there.


By late 2015, EU trade sanctions on Russia were in full swing. But Putin was as stubborn as the low oil prices and decided to bomb ‘terrorist’ (translating as anyone who disagrees with President Assad) positions in Syria at a rate of 60 airstrikes per day. Assad’s chemical weapon-wielding dictatorship could not have been more pleased. Mission accomplished?


Until the Syrian Army’s decisive victory on 22 December 2016, Russian bombers continued to pound rebel positions in Aleppo. Yet in Syria, unlike Ukraine, Putin has not been alone. The formation of a Russo-Turkish partnership became clear on 9 August 2016. Frustrated by America’s lack of support for Turkey’s detention of 26,000 coup ‘plotters’, Erdogan had a symbolic meeting with his Russian counterpart. 


A pattern is emerging from the South China Sea to the Mediterranean that reflects Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev’s talk of a “new cold war”. Brexit’s demoralising of the EU may be a part of that pattern, in which international organisations are losing the clout that they gained since 1989. Whilst Saddam Hussein was punished severely for his illegal actions in the 1990s, the 2010s have seen a return to international anarchy. For instance, China recently called a UN-mandated tribunal’s ruling in favour of the Philippines’ right to its own territory a “scrap of paper”. Sound familiar? Far-right elements in Germany used similar language to refer to the Treaty of Versailles. In an effort to counteract the EU and NATO, Russia has formed the Eurasian Economic Union and the Collective Security Treaty Organisation. Sound familiar? The Soviet Union once formed COMECON and the Warsaw Pact to counteract the American-led Marshall Plan and NATO. 


Cold War II is a fact of life. The US is “the great Satan” to Iran, a “heinous violator of human rights” to North Korea, and an “external threat” to Russia, suggesting that the US and its allies need to make efforts to put trust back into international institutions, in order to avoid the current cold war turning hot. The policy of appeasement advocated by Jeremy Corbyn also risks turning the current cold war hot: his apparent refusal to defend the Baltic states in the event of Russian attack could lead to trust in NATO collapsing. Consequently, Putin would see our Atlantic Alliance as weak. And President Trump now might have the power to self-destruct NATO, which is concerning given that he shares Corbyn’s isolationist foreign policy.


Before the United Nations and the era of collective security, war was worryingly frequent. Without surrendering a degree of sovereignty, states are particularly conflict-prone. Before the EU, the UN and 1989, there was anarchy. Now that anarchy is showing signs of returning, Brexit negotiations should pressure the closest possible union to counteract the forces pulling the EU, and indeed NATO, apart.


After World War I the formation of the League of Nations allowed peace to be kept for twenty years. The League’s fracturing precipitated the breakdown of this peace, largely due to the Anglo-French Hoare-Lavel Pact, which favoured secret negotiations over League-mandated diplomacy. A Brexit of sorts allowed war to happen in the 1930s, and it could do so again. History has, in recent years, showed signs of repeating itself, but it need not repeat itself ever again. 


Let us keep on this side of history. Let us reject international anarchy. Let us uphold the world after 1989.

Brexit: a leap into the unknown?

The following is an extract from my article for the INK magazine's Politics section (which I edit). It was published on 16 June 2016, but remains relevant in 2017, as we are yet to even begin the negotiations to leave the EU:

The press’s response to the migration crisis ranges from sympathy for innocent refugees to paranoia about an invading horde. Yet how will we respond in the Brexit vote on 23rd June? When it comes to it, should states behave selfishly or altruistically? Or, as international relations experts would put it, should we vote Leave and be “pluralist”, where self-preservation dictates what states do, or vote Remain and be “solidarist”, where common humanity is key? And if we vote Leave due to fears about migration, will we really be leaping into the unknown? This choice is far less modern than it appears...

To read on, visit: http://www.inkstudents.co.uk/article/brexit-a-leap-into-the-unknown

Wednesday, 18 January 2017

Word of the Week: Sovereignty


S
overeignty, whatever the word means, matters. From the monarchs of Renaissance Europe to the populists of Brexit Britain and Trumpist America, mere political control has never been enough. Instead, legal sovereignty has been the ultimate prize for monarchs, aristocrats and democrats down the ages. Today, the issue is more pressing than ever. Not only does the United Kingdom want to leave the European Union after its fateful referendum on 23 June 2016, but also, as of 17 January 2017, now desires to leave the Single Market for the sake of taking back 'sovereignty'. Thus the word, given its relevance, needs some elucidation. 

In 1576, Jean Bodin wrote Les Six livres de la République ('The Six Books of the Republic'). A student of Roman law and a member of the French Parlement, Bodin was concerned with the fountain of legal authority. For this pre-eminent political philosopher, that very fountain needed to be absolute, supreme, indivisible and perpetual. In other words, that fountain was to be a sovereign, which possessed sovereignty over a given territory and people. Thus sovereignty is Bodin's term for unified, unfettered legal authority. But here we must acknowledge that, whilst political power may be divided up among institutions, legal authority rests exclusively in the sovereign. Thomas Hobbes, in his 1651 book Leviathan (whose cover constitutes this entry's image), gave a good example of sovereign authority, as opposed to political power. As can be seen from the image, the body of the Leviathan - the sovereign 'Mortal God' or King of a state - is composed of many little figures. These figures represent the cogs in the machine of government, the political systems comprising the political entity as a whole. Each system has certain powers, such as trade or taxation. But they all derive their legitimate political power from the Leviathan, or sovereign monarch. Thus power may be divided in a state but authority is unified in an indivisible sovereign.Bodin and Hobbes agreed, therefore, that sovereignty was a tangible, vital part of a political entity's constitution, and that this sovereignty rested entirely in the legitimate sovereign, who, more often than not, was a monarch. But in 1762, Jean-Jaques Rousseau challenged this idea with his Du contrat social ('The social contract'). Having agreed that sovereignty was indivisible, philosophers were about to take a U-turn on where this indivisible sovereignty presided. In other words, Rousseau asked the question: who is sovereign?The resounding response of Enlightenment philosophers such as Immanuel Kant, Thomas Paine and Rousseau himself was: the people. Instead of the monarch being sovereign, philosophers in the 18th century asked whether sovereignty could be vested in the demos (people) themselves. Hence, after two millennia of dogmatic slumber, the concept of democracy was reborn in response to the question of sovereignty. Authority, philosophers agreed, had to rest somewhere, but the rightful question was: where? Democracy was the answer to this conundrum of sovereignty, as people looked back to the heyday of Athenian democracy, from c. 508 - 322 BC. Perhaps, after a whistle-stop tour of sovereignty, we can now define the elusive term once and for all. But, before we get over-excited, it is worth acknowledging that our definition is not restrictive. Instead, there are a myriad of definitions for sovereignty, each used for different contexts. To international relations theorists, sovereignty refers to equal rights under international law. To monarchists, sovereignty refers to the days when Kings and Queens had real influence over domestic affairs. To others, it's a more imaginative way of saying, 'Brexit means Brexit'. So let's restrict ourselves to pure political science, as the study of politics within a state, and try to define sovereignty as it has been presented by philosophers over the ages. Sovereignty is, in short, the fountain of supreme legal authority from which all legitimate political power flows within a state - whether that fountain be monarchical, aristocratic or democratic in nature. But here's some food for thought: clearly most democracies have a democratic sovereign. In the USA, that democratic sovereign is the people. Yet in the UK there is a monarchical sovereign - Elizabeth II - who possesses 'supreme legal authority'. But this authority is never exercised by Elizabeth II, such that some have claimed that the people or Parliament, and not the monarch, is the real sovereign of the UK. A.V. Dicey asserted in Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (1889) that 'The sovereignty of Parliament is, from a legal point of view, the dominant characteristic of our political institutions.' So in the UK, which once controlled one third of all land on Earth, who is sovereign: the Queen, Parliament or the people? I'll let you decide...